The reported suspension of Chris Charlton, NJPW’s English-language broadcaster, following his controversial remarks during the Wrestle Dynasty event, underscores the delicate nature of cross-promotional wrestling partnerships. NJPW and AEW have worked extensively to build a positive relationship, evidenced by their collaborative events like Forbidden Door and now Wrestle Dynasty. However, Charlton’s pointed critique of AEW President Tony Khan and his dismissal of AEW’s contributions seem to have disrupted the spirit of mutual respect fostered between the promotions.
Context of the Comments
Charlton’s remarks included:
- Calling Tony Khan a “money mark,” a term with connotations of financial backing without substantial wrestling credibility.
- Devaluing the AEW accomplishments of former NJPW stars, including Kenny Omega and Will Ospreay.
- Critiquing AEW’s Continental Classic, which was inspired by NJPW’s storied G1 Climax tournament.
These comments struck a nerve, as they not only challenged AEW’s credibility but also put a negative spotlight on a night meant to celebrate collaboration.
Reaction and Consequences
- Suspension Details: While backstage reactions were reportedly mixed, Charlton’s suspension is set at two months, indicating NJPW’s commitment to maintaining a respectful tone in its dealings with AEW.
- Immediate Impact: Charlton’s absence during the subsequent New Year’s Dash broadcast left a noticeable gap, with his partner broadcasting solo until being joined mid-show by TJP, a wrestler and occasional commentator.
Broader Implications
Charlton’s suspension highlights the potential challenges inherent in cross-promotional relationships:
- Cultural Sensitivities: With NJPW and AEW coming from different wrestling traditions, fostering mutual respect is vital. Comments that appear dismissive of one promotion risk undoing significant goodwill.
- Brand Loyalty vs. Collaboration: Broadcasters and talent often walk a fine line between loyalty to their home promotions and supporting collaborative efforts. Charlton’s comments, though perhaps reflecting his passion for NJPW, clashed with the event’s ethos.
- Fan Reaction: Fans of both promotions are likely divided, with some viewing Charlton’s suspension as censorship, while others see it as a necessary move to preserve professionalism.
Kenny Omega’s Role
Omega’s victory over Gabe Kidd marked a triumphant return to NJPW after years in AEW and a lengthy medical absence. His involvement in the event was symbolic, bridging the gap between AEW and NJPW while reigniting interest in inter-promotional storytelling. Charlton’s remarks during this high-stakes match added a layer of controversy that could overshadow Omega’s performance.
Moving Forward
NJPW’s swift action demonstrates their intent to uphold professionalism in their broadcasts. Charlton’s eventual return will likely come with tighter guidelines, ensuring future commentary aligns with NJPW’s collaborative goals. For AEW and NJPW, the incident may serve as a reminder of the care required to balance brand loyalty with respect for partners.
This situation is a testament to how cross-promotional partnerships in wrestling require more than just in-ring collaboration—they demand consistent respect and cohesion across all aspects, including commentary.