Things We Loved:
- Kenny Omega’s Impressive Return
Kenny Omega’s return at Maximum Carnage was one of the highlights of the show. After multiple returns over the past month, this one was particularly special as it showcased how well Omega had recovered and adapted his in-ring style. The match against Brian Cage, while not an instant classic, was a solid display of Omega’s ability to sell his midsection injury, which adds an extra layer of drama to his matches going forward. Cage’s contributions helped make this match compelling, with some great spots like the superplex and powerbomb. This is the kind of match that didn’t need to be a show-stealer but still kept the audience engaged, setting the stage for more intense showdowns down the line. Fans are now looking forward to the potential of an Omega-Ospreay match that could take place at Grand Slam Australia. - Megan Bayne’s Dynamite Debut
The Women’s Casino Gauntlet Match marked a major moment for AEW’s women’s division, with Megan Bayne finally making her Dynamite debut. This match not only showcased some incredible talent but also brought attention to the increasing depth of AEW’s women’s roster. Bayne’s presence adds a new dimension to AEW’s women’s scene, and her debut in this high-stakes match was a memorable moment, leaving fans eager to see more from her in the future. - Samoa Joe’s Return
While not the focal point of the show, Samoa Joe’s return was universally well-received by fans. His charisma and experience bring something special to AEW, and his presence in the locker room is a boost to both talent and fans. Sometimes it’s the subtle, understated returns like this one that can have the most impact, and Joe’s reappearance certainly elevated the show.
Things We Hated:
- MVP’s Underwhelming Return
MVP’s much-hyped return to in-ring action was a major letdown. Despite AEW hyping it up as a monumental comeback after two years away, the actual match didn’t live up to expectations. MVP’s participation felt minimal, and the big moment of his return seemed hollow when Shelton Benjamin ended up getting the pin. The match itself wasn’t bad, but it certainly wasn’t the spectacular return that AEW had built it up to be. If MVP wasn’t going to be involved in the finish, it begs the question why he was brought back into the ring in the first place. It was a missed opportunity to make MVP’s return more meaningful. - Jeff Jarrett vs. MJF Promo Battle
This segment was hard to watch for all the wrong reasons. Jeff Jarrett and MJF’s promo exchange went on for far too long and lacked the chemistry needed to keep it engaging. MJF, as always, delivered sharp, biting insults, but Jarrett’s responses fell flat, especially when the crowd started chanting “He’s our scumbag!” at MJF. The back-and-forth felt forced, awkward, and stretched out unnecessarily. The insults between the two — especially MJF’s low blow about Jarrett’s friendship with Owen Hart — felt distasteful and detracted from the overall quality of the segment. It just didn’t click, and the attempt to shock the audience with controversial remarks seemed misplaced. - The Women’s Casino Gauntlet Match Falling Short
Despite the exciting debut of Megan Bayne, the Women’s Casino Gauntlet Match didn’t feel as impactful as it could have. The match lacked the energy and pacing needed to truly make it a memorable moment in AEW’s history. It was somewhat overshadowed by other events on the show, and while it was great for spotlighting new talent, it didn’t quite reach the potential fans were hoping for.
Conclusion:
While AEW Dynamite had some standout moments, including Kenny Omega’s stellar return and the introduction of fresh faces like Megan Bayne, it also had its share of missteps. MVP’s return felt lackluster, and the Jarrett vs. MJF feud is showing signs of overstaying its welcome. AEW still has plenty of talent and potential, but the execution of some storylines and segments felt off this week.
What did you think of this episode? Were you a fan of Omega’s performance, or did you find the MVP segment frustrating as well?